Featured Image
The AI content debate often misses the point. It's not about AI versus humans—it's about knowing when each approach delivers the best results for your goals and audience.
After producing millions of words of content through both AI and human writers, we've developed a clear framework for making this decision strategically.
The AI Content Debate: Missing the Point
The conversation around AI content usually falls into two camps:
- AI Enthusiasts: "AI can do everything faster and cheaper!"
- Traditionalists: "AI content is soulless and will kill your brand!"
Both are wrong—and right. The truth lies in strategic application.
Where AI Content Excels
AI should be your primary tool for:
1. High-Volume, Low-Complexity Content
- Product descriptions (especially for large catalogs)
- Meta descriptions and title tags
- FAQ responses
- Internal documentation
2. Data-Driven Content
- Reports and summaries
- Analytics interpretations
- Competitive analyses
- Market research compilations
3. Variations and Adaptations
- A/B test variations
- Localization of existing content
- Format repurposing (blog to social)
- Personalization at scale
4. First Drafts and Outlines
- Initial drafts for human refinement
- Content outlines and structures
- Research compilation
- Interview preparation
Where Humans Are Essential
Human writers are irreplaceable for:
1. Thought Leadership
Original insights, industry predictions, and contrarian viewpoints require human expertise and credibility.
2. Emotional Storytelling
Customer stories, brand narratives, and content designed to create emotional connections need the human touch.
3. Complex Technical Content
Deep technical documentation, expert guides, and content requiring specialized knowledge.
4. Crisis Communications
Sensitive topics, PR responses, and communications requiring nuanced tone.
5. Brand Voice Development
Establishing (not maintaining) your brand voice requires human creativity and strategic thinking.
The Decision Framework
Use this flowchart to decide:
Content Creation Decision Tree
- Q: Is this high-stakes content? (Brand reputation, legal, crisis)
→ Yes: Human writer required - Q: Does this require original insights?
→ Yes: Human with AI assistance - Q: Is this content being scaled? (100+ pieces)
→ Yes: AI with human review - Q: Is this content templatable?
→ Yes: AI generation - Default: Hybrid approach (AI draft, human refinement)
The Hybrid Approach: Best of Both Worlds
Most content should follow a hybrid workflow:
The 80/20 Content Model
- AI handles 80%: Research, first drafts, variations, optimization
- Humans handle 20%: Strategy, insights, voice, quality control
This model delivers maximum efficiency while maintaining quality.
Quality Checklist: AI or Human
Regardless of who (or what) creates your content, it must pass these tests:
- ☐ Factually accurate and verifiable
- ☐ Aligned with brand voice
- ☐ Provides unique value to readers
- ☐ Well-structured and scannable
- ☐ Optimized for the target channel
- ☐ Includes appropriate calls-to-action
- ☐ Free of errors and awkward phrasing
The Bottom Line
The best content strategies don't choose between AI and human—they strategically deploy both. Focus on the outcome (great content) not the method (AI vs human).